Influencers are a dying marketing strategy – it’s time to focus on UGC & CGC instead
In the ever-evolving digital landscape, what used to work one day is often replaced by something new the next. The emergence of TikTok as a popular social media platform and the increasing need for constant video content has influenced how we create and consume online content. This shift has created new opportunities for brands to interact with their audience in a meaningful way and build trust, explains Madelene Ragno, founder of MADE. Marketing.
Recently, we’ve seen a noticeable shift from traditional influencer marketing as a primary marketing strategy to UGC and CGC.
User-generated content (UGC) and consumer-generated content (CGC) have now taken centre stage and it’s time for your brand to get its dancing shoes on.
4 reasons why UGC and CGC are taking on influencer marketing
1. Saturation and lack of authenticity
Over the past decade, we’ve seen the rise of influencer marketing and how this environment has been saturated with sponsored content. In turn, your customers are becoming increasingly aware of the commercial nature of influencer endorsements and can often view them as disingenuous.
The credibility and authenticity that once made influencers effective brand ambassadors is now being called into question.
2. Declining reach and engagement
Another factor contributing to the decline of influencer engagement is the decreasing reach and engagement rates of influencer posts. With the growth of social media platforms and the ever-expanding pool of influencers, competition for attention has intensified.
Algorithms on platforms like Instagram have changed, and organic reach for influencer content has decreased over time. The over-saturation of influencer-sponsored posts has also led to reduced user engagement, as audiences are fatigued by repetitive content.
Being created from the perspective of a real user or customer experience, UGC and CGC allow your audience to organically connect and relate to the seemingly ‘everyday’ person on their screen.
3. Rising costs and shifting priorities
Influencer marketing campaigns often come with big price tags. As the demand for influencers and their audiences has increased, so have their fees. This pricing model may not be sustainable or justifiable for every brand, especially for smaller businesses with limited marketing budgets.
UGC and CGC can be affordable and scalable options, as most creators develop content on a more suitable hourly or per-video rate.
It’s also common practice for influencers to enforce a time limit on the use of their content (e.g. three months or one year). Content creators are much more flexible, with many not enforcing time limits. In some cases, your UGC or CGC creator may even provide you with raw footage so you can create new content to use across all your platforms over and over again.
To keep your momentum going on social platforms, it’s important to regularly post video content. Instead of paying a premium for one video, working with multiple UGC or CGC creators is much more cost-effective to get more content (videos and images) at a lower cost.
4. Social proof and trust
UGC and CGC hold a unique advantage when it comes to building trust and social proof. Consumers tend to trust the opinions and experiences of their peers more than those of influencers, who are often viewed as paid endorsers.
UGC and CGC provide a platform for customers to share unbiased reviews, testimonials and user experiences, giving potential customers a more authentic and relatable perspective. This user-generated content carries a level of credibility that can sway purchasing decisions and foster a sense of trust in a brand.
All in all, user-generated content and consumer-generated content have the potential to provide brands with authentic, cost-effective strategies that can provide higher returns on investment, as well as create a new way to connect with and build your audience.
The advantages are hard to dispute, no matter how you look at it.
Want more? Get our newsletter delivered straight to your inbox! Follow Kochie’s Business Builders on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and LinkedIn.
Trending
Digital Marketing Colours, fonts, icons: 7 design fundamentals to make your website stand out from the pack
Competitions Share your anonymous business confessions
Digital Marketing 7 tactics to up your video marketing game
Marketing Advice How to win over customers and turn them into raving fans
Digital Marketing Lululemon’s spam email fine a lesson for small business
Commonly known as a Marketing , Madelene is a seasoned professional with over 8 years of experience in the consumer goods industry, specialising in health food and beverages, beauty and fashion.
She is the founder and CEO of MADE. Marketing., a boutique marketing agency that has carved a niche for itself by delivering exceptional results for style-led brands.
madecreativeco.com.au
Tags
Big ideas for small business — straight to your inbox
Get the best small business tips, news and advice straight to your inbox! No junk, just real-world insights to help you grow.
Sign up now.
Now read...
Four real ways to build business in the digital age
In 2026, social media is louder than ever….
Your customers are finding you through AI. You just can’t see it yet
When ChatGPT arrived in late 2022, many people…
Lululemon’s spam email fine a lesson for small business
Activewear giant Lululemon has been hit with a…
From search to success: How an electrician’s website upgrade increased bookings and revenue
Like most trades, electricians belong to a generic-sounding…
More from Business Builders
Four real ways to build business in the digital age
In 2026, social media is louder than ever….
Your customers are finding you through AI. You just can’t see it yet
When ChatGPT arrived in late 2022, many people…
Lululemon’s spam email fine a lesson for small business
Activewear giant Lululemon has been hit with a…
From search to success: How an electrician’s website upgrade increased bookings and revenue
Like most trades, electricians belong to a generic-sounding…
Why earned media, not AI or SEO is your brand awareness secret weapon
Search Engine Optimisation (SEO) has been around for…
Colours, fonts, icons: 7 design fundamentals to make your website stand out from the pack
A website that looks great and works hard…






